Home » News » The Crisis of Leadership and Legitimacy within Ethiopia’s TPLF Minority Regime

The Crisis of Leadership and Legitimacy within Ethiopia’s TPLF Minority Regime

by Netsanet Bulto

TPLF Ethnic Federal Apartheid

Ever since the death of the late TPLF chairman and Prime Minister, Meles Zenawi, the Tigrayan People’s Liberation Front (TPLF) has lacked a similarly dominant personality able to maintain consensus, either thru charisma, intrigue, or both.  This condition has given rise within the TPLF to internal divisions and animosities. Abay Woldu, the current president of the regional state of Tigray, holds the chairmanship of the party. But he does not wield the power, nor command the respect, the late Meles held. This leadership vacuum has led to an intense, internal power struggle within the TPLF. Stories from multiple and credible sources abound to this effect.

The worst schism to emerge is between the domestic and military intelligence agencies. Fissures also have opened between the ruling party, security agencies, the military and the bureaucracy.  Open and confidential sources indicate that friction within and between state organs, involving the regime’s most important personalities, has created an unprecedented crisis.

Torn between party loyalty and popular anti-government sentiment, important partners within the ruling coalition, such as the Oromo People’s Democracy Organization (OPDO), the Oromo wing of the ruling EPRDF, have begun to assert their independence from the once-omnipotent TPLF faction. The result has been the purging of thousands of mid- and low-level OPDO officials in an attempt to maintain party cohesion in the face of popular anti-government protests engulfing the Oromo region. However, sources report that new recruits and appointees meant to replace those purged are also quietly resigning. Open defiance of the regime and the so-called “Command Post” administering martial law has become widespread throughout Oromia and is openly expressed in social gatherings and in public.

While OPDO has been under organizational stress since the recent resurgence of Oromo protests, Abadula Gemeda, the speaker of parliament and former president of the Oromo region, has stepped into the breach. Abadula is a close associates of Gen. Samora Yunus, the military chief of staff, who has been calling the shots since the implementation of martial law. Samora’s position as head of the notorious Command Post is reportedly a cause of resentment within the military’s upper echelons, including his longtime rival, Lt. General Saere Mekonnen, until recently Commander of the Northern Front and currently Head of Training Main Department of the Ministry of Defense.

A Samora loyalist,  Lt. General Abraha Wodlemariam, a.k.a Quarter, the notorious war criminal responsible for the massacre of thousands of civilians in the ongoing counter insurgency in the Ogadan region while in his capacity as a commander of the Eastern Front and in concert with another  butcher, the President of the Ogaden region, has been appointed to a new position of Chief of Operations of Defense. This is yet another clear indication that Lt. General Seare is, once again, sidelined, and Samora’s grip and consolidation of power over the military is becoming more than clear.  It has been reported that Security Chief Getachew Assefa, Abay Tesehay, Sibehat Nega, and others, including former Airforce Commander, Maj. General Aebebe Tekelehamina, aka Jobe, have been actively working behind the scenes to have Lt. Genera Seare Mekonnen replace Samora as Chief of staff of the Defense forces of the TPLF dominated military and state.

As well known, the former commander of the Airforce, Gen. Abebe, like his close friend Tasdakn Gebre Tesnay, former Chief of Staff, has made his deep frustrations public at the state of affairs in Ethiopia under the current regime. In a series of articles published by the Amharic weekly, the Reporter,  in  the past year, the retired General has called the current situation in Ethiopia one that is endangering the security and survival of Ethiopia , and therefore, as the most potent threat, not only to the regime, but also  to the  multiethnic national fabric. In his latest article, retired Maj. Gen. Abebe recounts pervasive corruption, including at the highest levels of government, absence of good governance, lack of a democratic space, human rights abuse, and the inability of the regime to respond to popular demands, lack of political will and proper mechanisms in place to make the necessary changes.

These salient features all the more discussed as factors that would somehow converge to destabilize Ethiopia and pose the most serious security threat to Ethiopia. The former General has indeed the courage to ring the alarm bells to the otherwise deaf ears of the regime and its leaders who are in disarray. Although, one may argue that the general is off the mark as regard to the correct prognosis, which cannot be other than a transitional process towards a genuine democratic order for the country that involves all stakeholders and political forces.

The other key leaders of OPDO are Lemma Megersa, Beker Shale (until recently) and Abiye Mohammed, the former minister of science and technology, who maintains a low public profile. While close to chief of staff Samora, this coterie of OPDO’s bosses are, like their patron, Abadula, at odds with Getachew Assefa, the chief of security. Getachew, in turn, is reported to have the backing of Abay Tsehay, and Sibehat Nega, both TPLF heavyweights still wielding perhaps the greatest influence within the TPLF in the wake of the Oromo protest that rocked the region in the past eighteen months. Lemma Megersa, a onetime security official, has a firm allegiance to Abadula, who was instrumental in his rise to power as president of the Oromo region.  Unlike the rocky relationships most OPDO leaders now have with those of the security services. Lemma is known to report regularly to Abdadula about communications he still maintains with security chief Getachew.

Haile Mariam Desgalegn has turned out to be a lame duck Prime Minister and a pawn in the never-ending power struggles of the TPLF power brokers. He is said to be close to General Samora’s group. One recent clue to this is his recent rebuff of a report released by Aba Tsehaye, a close supporter and ally of Getachew Assefa, concerning the incompetence permeating the executive branch’s cabinet and state ministers.

These ministers were appointed by Haile Mariam, the prime minster during the state of emergency as part of an “in-depth renewal” promising good governance, less corruption and responsiveness to popular demands for change. But neither this much-vaunted Tilk Tehadiso, nor the change of cabinet and state ministers, has delivered or appeased public anger in the wake of the Oromo and Amhara protests. The Ethiopian people have largely perceived the Tilk Tehadeso as yet another of the regime’s gimmicks to cover up and reverse the growing illegitimacy, crisis of confidence and near-total rejection by the Ethiopian people that have plagued it in the past eighteen months and were expressed by the massive protests in the Oromo and Amhara regions.

Leadership of the regime’s Amhara coalition partner, ANDM, has also been at odds with its TPLF partner to a point of approaching open confrontation.  Like the OPDO, ANDM’s ranks are rife with resentment and discontent over TPLF domination and the heavy repression that followed protests around Gondar and Gojam in the Amhara region.

The TPLF-controlled military is also suffering from low morale. Desertions and defections, especially by the Amhara and Oromo soldiers whose ethnic groups comprise most of the lower ranks, have sharply increased in the rebellious areas.  The defection of entire platoons and companies has occurred on several occasions. Anxiety and confusion over such developments now afflicts nearly all military forces at all levels, including the Agazi Division, a special unit used for repression that’s widely despised since its massacre of hundreds of unarmed protesters in the aftermath of the stolen 2005 election. This trend has worsened since the most recent Oromo and Amhara protests. Recruitment quotas are unmet, chronically so in the Amhara, Oromo and, to a lesser extent, other regions.  ESAT and other media outlets have recently covered the severity of this problem confronting the regime.

Another trouble that has been a chronic headache for the TPLF military and security top brass has been the emerging armed popular resistance in Norther part of Ethiopia. The military leadership had held several secret meetings on how to control the situation in Northern Ethiopia, including a discussion without reaching an agreement, about the possibility of invading Eritrea and thereby wiping out the armed resistance groups based there. This option has been objected by elements of the military and security who understand the extremely low state  morale in the army, the chronic defection and desertions plaguing it ,  as well as  with their bitter memory of the military’s  tragic loss at the battle of Tsoerna in June of 2016 which the TPLF commanders ill-advisedly  launched against Eritreans, resulting in  total carnage , hundreds of the Ethiopian armed forces  killed and several hundred others  lightly and heavy wounded, crowding Mekele Hospital and other medical facilities in Tigray.  One consideration related to this view on the part of those who oppose military measures against Eritrea has to do with the very fear harbored by TPLF leaders. They lack confidence because they very well know that the army is dominated by Tigrayan commanders from top to bottom, the army has a very low morale, and top it all they are very much aware that the army is fully aware of the malfeasance and massive corruption of its top brass. Thus, they surmise the armed forces as it is constituted today   cannot be relied upon for a full scale war with the tough and hardened Eritrean defense forces. In addition, the tough and rough terrain that is known to give a high advantage to defending Eritrean forces in an event of an invasion by the TPLF led Ethiopian Armed forces.

Getachew’s National Intelligence and Security Service, known as NISS, is struggling to maintain its status and expand its turf. NISS is increasingly engaged in staving off challenges to its influence from the military intelligence service led by Maj. Gen. Gebre Dilla, a close ally of General Samora Yunus. Defense’s Military intelligence Department is said to be competing for power by overextending its tentacles and fielding agents of its own down to the kebele, or neighborhood, level and into all kinds of organizations, including religious ones, generating apprehension and visible hostility on the part of Getachew and NISS.

Recent leaks about infighting and power struggles within the ruling political elite are due in part to this development. They describe Samora and his own military intelligence chief, Gebre Dilla, using the state of emergency and the command post apparatus as a cover to widen their jurisdiction and infringe on the civilian intelligence services’ authority. This contest has added to the animosities, factionalism, and internal divisions affecting the minority regime.

Underneath these visible manifestations of discord, the demoralization infecting the military has spread to NISS as well. Intelligence sources attribute this to the repeated failure to control emerging political conditions throughout the county—viewed by many observers as a decaying political system cracking at the seams–and inability to understand the new fissures. Adding to this institutional state of anxiety is the budding armed resistance of Patriotic Ginbot 7 forces, now gaining momentum and intensity in their attacks on military, security, and regime administrative targets in several parts of the country, especially in the northern and southern Gondar areas of the Amhara region.

3 comments

  1. Personally I take every attempt or any analysis made by various opposition sits with “a grain of salt”.

    There is a reason for this ; we have much stored in our repertoire about the deviant nature of TPLF.
    For instance we had the first TPLF crack March 2001. How does the TPLF handles its first split? Well a group of 12 or so central and polite bureau members decided to revolt. Then, the deceased leader of the TPLF smart man moved swiftly to take action. He got the security chief eliminated; followed by the reshuffling of the Army command . General Tsedkan was removed from armed forces chief of staff, and replaced by the loyal Mohamed Younis, other wise known as Samora. The then defense minister Tsege Abraha was sentenced 6 years. At the end of it all Melese came out to be the undisputed leader of TPLF and the army. And the rest of the faction members were either have been shown the door out or forced to repent and made lame duck members of TPLF. One might think Tsege Abraha and Gebru Asrat could have easily joined the opposition and persuade TPLF to the negotiating table. But that never materialized you see! Why so? Because ,”Birds of the same feather flock together”.

    The we have the incident of the death of Melese. We all remember how many people thought the end of TPLF is here. Time proved them all to have been wrong. We have forgotten the many tricks of TPLF.If it wants TPLF can circulate rumors just to gauge the response of the opposition. If it wants she can produce smoke screen such as military buildup in the border ,and yet this may all mean to draw attention of her opponents. I don’t believe for any second TPLfits at this stage of the game will let themselves be divide. They will do anything to cement their differences and continue as tightly knit group against the odds than to permit division within their rank that will land them to a sudden death.

    The only sure thing we can say is since the TPLF molder, Tecola Hagos’s article entitled, “We Ethiopians Get The Government We Deserve”. The country is under the TPL:F military command.In his piece he said the following.

    “I offer here my alternative solution to use the Turkish Government model…….First step is to establish by the new Representatives a central independent military command consisting of five senior commanders from the Army, the Air Force, and the Police. Once established the military command becomes a self-perpetuating command board with a Chief-of-Staff as its chairman…”.

    As far as I am concerned no one ,except GOD, knows how things are to be resolved.

    Fellow country man, in retrospective I think how great it would have been ,if captain Moges W/Mikael’s faction within the derg or your dad’s attempt to t stop Mengistu could have succeeded.

  2. Although the Fascist TPLF regime has managed to hold onto power for the last twenty five years with guns and bullets and by virtue of its many-layered hierarchies mainly horizontally and with subdivision vertically branching out to security and military division, there have still been constraints arising from internal feud among grand bosses, although no single member in the TPLF regime will put their organization in greater danger for individuals special interest, but certainly the fascist regime has been threatened by the mass uprising both in Oromia and Amhara regions coupled with the remaining regions with similar collaborative uprising leading to the regime’s bosses to have been subjected to severe unpleasant feelings, stress and anxiety of all sorts. yes, a good number of soldiers mainly low-ranking ones and a less number of mid ranking and sub-high ranking military officers have been defected from the regime and have joined freedom fighters. some who couldn’t join the freedom fighters had taken unwavering military actions against the regime; Well, in reality, the regime has escalated a war against the people that is certainly unwinnable, although the martial law that the regime’s bosses imposed on Ethiopians has given the regime’s owners uncrowded opportunity to breath in and out with a little soothing effect, if the crime bosses think a remedy to the inevitable demise of their existence, well, they must have been misdiagnosed their own ailment and prescribed to themselves ineffective and unworkable medicine. What has had worked and lately had been witnessed by the millions that low ranking soldiers have stepped up attacks on the regime resulting in the crime bosses hurling accusation in panic on one another one saying to the other negligently exposing their existence to a shark attack.

    When the rumor is coming from unexpected and unknown sources or unidentified one, it usually create uneasiness in the non-military intelligent circles with Getachew Assefa, the psydonyme of (the intelligence head ) taking extra precaution not to step on a mine leading to meet early fate of his. Yes, Getachew Assefa is quite aware of General Sammora has become frail and fragile not only because of his age, it is also varieties of diseases that he has contracted while in the wild and was the first in the TPLF diagnosed with HIV and MS. it is likely he will not make it through this calendar year. Yes, General Sammora is the least educated and is at the bottom on intelligence scale guy in the TPLF family who barely understands written documents. Getachew Assefa is quite shallow a person with similar traits with that of the dead robber, Meles Zenawi; at any given situation wherever his work takes him to, no matter how he is surrounded by abundant security, he still feels nervous mainly because of haphazard situations arising from unexpected factors. in many instants Getachew Assefa has shown hesitancy in sitting with General Sammora for a joint discussion on reviewing on both intelligence departments insisting that General Sammora failed to track down missing spies in the military.

    Hopefully, both General Sammora and Getachew Assffa will stand side by side and stand trial before the million; even, if it means death comes on General Sammora before he stands trial, it doesn’t mean he will be exempted from standing before the justice. But, unless either one of them commits adultery with their wives, say, General Sammora gives HIV to Getachew Assfa’s wife, it is only in this situation the two crime bosses will for sure pull guns on each other.

  3. Ittu Aba Farda

    I like this article due to the obvious fact that it is well written. The author has assured us that there is a slow but serious fault line emerging between the various regional groups that had formed the ruling nomenclature EPRDF. According to this article every regional ‘emperors’ or at least the two giant partners with more than 70 percent of the country’s entire population are at a serious odds with a group with only 6% of the population. That is huge. 70% vs 6%? I think the valkyrie will start singing very soon!!!

    It was around 1975-76 someone told me here before he made a trip back to the old country that there was a serious mutiny in the Air Force, the Navy and many units in the army. Mengistu was on life support. His oxygen tank was about to be snipped by the popular urban uprising and it is time to be part of history. Did that happen? Well I am still mourning that well educated countryman!!!

    I will hope and pray that that Promised Land of democratic governance is around the corner for every walking, breathing Ethiopian. There will be no easier solution than seeing despots imploding within with the population staying aside and watching at a safe distance.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*